Don’t dismiss Madeleine Madden’s message

At 7:30pm on Sunday, 24 October 2010, Australia’s TV channels broadcast a young Aboriginal girl’s plea to end, within the next 20 years, the inequality between our Indigenous people and the rest of us. I won’t go in to what she said (you can read the GenerationOne media statement here) but I do want to talk about is the ignorant reaction of some, ah… ‘unenlightened’ people to her message.

Many people in Australia seem to think that because Aboriginal people seem to get ‘more government handouts and benefits than white Australians’ or because ‘they get preferential treatment in many areas of society … over other Australians because supposedly they are a minority’, there is no inequality.

Those arguments are simplistic, absurd and inexcusably ignorant of Australian history.

Yes, some Aboriginals do get benefits – health care concessions, lower interest rates on home loans, and so on – that most of us don’t, but so what? Most Aboriginals are in a very different situation to the rest of us, particularly us white Australians. We don’t tend to be discriminated against when seeking employment. We generally live longer and healthier lives. We don’t have a history of being oppressed.

Frankly, Aboriginal Australians are among the most disadvantaged indigenous people in the world. I defy anyone to prove otherwise. While it’s true that they live in a civilised, technologically advanced, democratic country, for much of their history since colonisation they haven’t been treated like Australian citizens (they’re still not recognised in the Constitution) and have been left to live in third world conditions.

There’s a line in a Blue King Brown song that says something like, “White man holds the key to black man’s identity”. I used to disagree with this, thinking that Aboriginals needed to stop allowing themselves to be victims. I was wrong. It’s white Australia that is treating them like victims, like children, thinking that we know best and they should do what we tell them to; that they should assimilate and be white like us (if only in lifestyle).

There are no simple solutions, and assimilation or segregation is not the answer. Continuing to throw money at the problems, many of which white Australians have created, will not repair 200-plus years of damage.

But we can start with trying to understand their culture; to understand why they may be reluctant to sever a traditional connection with their land in order to find employment in our larger towns or cities; to understand the challenges they face every day, even the ones who do move away or have long since lived in our cities; to understand the underlying causes behind the violence and the drinking; and to accept that we have a responsibility to help them so that one day they don’t need special programs or benefits to enable them to simply live.

So to the haters out there: No, Madeleine didn’t have a political agenda and she wasn’t after more money for Aboriginals. She was after better understanding of what her people face every day. She was asking for all of us to help her people stand up and overcome Aboriginal disadvantage, to take some responsibility for helping Indigenous Australians where successive governments have failed.

She was asking us to be the Australians we like to think we are, but too often are not.

Tagged , , , ,

2 thoughts on “Don’t dismiss Madeleine Madden’s message

  1. Stephanie says:

    Blogs like this are good, and I’m a firm believer in the health benefits of ranting (in a safe environment otherwise you end up yelling at people). I know our English grammar lets us down on this front but “long since lived in our cities” does not sound great. This reinforces people’s ideas of Aborignal culture as something that stood still in time when colonisers first arrived in Australia. No society is like this, culture is always changing over time as technology is advanced and as different societies interact. Australian history is a shared history where inequality and repression has featured strongly, but shared history is about more than just that.

    People who make comments such as “Aboriginal people seem to get more government handouts and benefits than white Australians” or because “they get preferential treatment in many areas of society … over other Australians because supposedly they are a minority”, make them on the basis of racism. We still have a long way to go before we can realise racial equality.

    Everything that is done in the name of “the war on terror” is justified by the catch cry of ‘defending our way of life’, in this instance it’s a politcal blindfold but it does speak to people’s natures. Isn’t it normal that people want to preserve their way of life and their culture? What I liked about Madeleine Madden’s speech was that she addressed the desire of Aborignal people (like any other Australians) to be given a fair go and have a chance to receive an education that may lead them to meaningful employment not discrimination.

    Australia is a diverse nation, the one constant about nature is it’s diversity. People should not be discriminated against because of their different ways of life.

    On another note doesn’t it shit you that you have to describe yourself as an ‘athiest’, it’s the equivalent of introducing yourself and saying, “oh by the way I don’t believe there’s a Santa Claus.”

  2. bet365 says:

    how are you I was luck to approach your website in bing
    your topic is fine
    I obtain a lot in your website really thanks very much
    btw the theme of you blog is really superb
    where can find it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: